Slavery was practiced in ancient Greece and Rome, throughout Africa and the Middle East, in Asia, and across the Americas long before the United States existed. The institution varied enormously across time and place. What distinguished slavery in the United States was not that it was the only cruel or hereditary form of slavery, but the particular combination of racial ideology, permanent hereditary status, commercial agriculture, legal exclusion, and political power that developed around it.
American slavery was not necessarily more brutal in every respect than every other form of slavery. Enslaved people in the Caribbean, Brazil, the ancient world, and elsewhere could experience extraordinary violence, exploitation, family separation, and premature death. In some settings, mortality was even higher than in the American South.
The distinctive American combination was the development of a society in which racial ancestry, inherited lifetime bondage, property law, plantation capitalism, and political power reinforced one another. Its consequences did not end with emancipation: the racial hierarchy built around slavery continued to shape segregation, citizenship, wealth, and civil rights.
Few things expose the absurdity and power of American racial categories quite like the phenomenon of passing: a black person, often of mixed ancestry, living as white in a society that classified people by race and attached vastly different rights, opportunities, and dangers to those classifications. In a country where slavery made blackness synonymous with bondage, and where generations of laws and customs sought to police the boundary between black and white, the ability to cross that boundary could mean access to education, employment, safety, and social standing otherwise denied. But passing was rarely as simple as changing one's identity. It could mean concealing family history, abandoning loved ones, and living with the constant possibility of exposure. What appeared to be an individual choice was inseparable from a larger system that made racial identity both a deeply personal matter and a public verdict.
The subject has inspired a remarkable body of American literature, from nineteenth-century narratives shaped by slavery and emancipation to modern novels and contemporary nonfiction exploring identity, family, and belonging. Some stories portray passing as an escape from an oppressive racial order; others examine its emotional costs, its ethical ambiguities, and the fragile assumptions on which racial classifications rest. Together, these books ask unsettling questions: What makes someone Black or white? Who gets to decide? And what does it mean to gain freedom by concealing a part of oneself? The answers reveal as much about the society that demanded passing as they do about the people who chose—or were compelled—to do it.
Inspired by a couple of recent reads, I've compiled a list of books that I have read that deal with passing. (Italics means that I'm sharing the publisher's blurb, not a Histocrats Bookshelf review.)
The relationship between Thomas Jefferson and his enslaved half-sister-in-law Sally Hemings has been the fodder of public comment and speculation since the early 1800s. Many of the descendants of their relationship have made the decision to "pass" over the years.
History by a Hair: Thomas Jefferson, Sally Hemings & Solving a 200-Year-Old Mystery. Richard Kurin. Crown, 2026. 432 pages.
Being a historian is very much like being a detective, both relying on gathering clues, following dead ends, evaluating evidence, and piecing together a whole story from incomplete bits. If you like detective stories, if you like CSI, if you like history, this is a great book for you about one of the oldest mysteries in American history. For over two hundred years, it's been alleged that Thomas Jefferson, the founder who so eloquently described freedom and equality as American ideals while enslaving over 600 people over the course of his lifetime, had a decades-long relationship with the enslaved Sally Hemings, fathering several of her children. Hemings family lore over the decades had maintained that the relationship, first discussed in print in the early 1800s by Jefferson's political opponents, was factual. Many diehard Jefferson apologists and direct descendants of Jefferson, via his wife Martha, vehemently denied the charge. In the late 1990s, DNA tests proved that a Jefferson male (perhaps Jefferson or his brother or nephews) had fathered at least one of the Hemings children, but couldn't prove any stronger connection, and deniers were still unmoved. A major breakthrough occurred in 2011 when a few strands of hair were found in the so-called "Jefferson Bible," the collection of New Testament passages from various Bibles that Jefferson personally cut and pasted together for his own use. Richard Kurin, Smithsonian historian and museum official, had a brainstorm: Could these be Jefferson's hairs and could they be used, with today's more advanced DNA techniques, to prove, once and for all, the paternity truth? For the next 15 years, Kurin and a top team of genealogists, historians, archaeologists, curators, and DNA specialists worked to find and identify samples of living and dead Jefferson and Hemings descendants in order to build and to compare genomes to settle the matter once and for all. All were determined to "follow truth wherever it may lead," as Jefferson himself wrote. Spoiler alert: the mystery is resolved, and the book is a fascinating account of all the work that went into the solution.
It brings to life not only Sally Hemings and Thomas Jefferson but also their children and Hemings's siblings, who shared a father with Jefferson's wife, Martha. The Hemingses of Monticello sets the family's compelling saga against the backdrop of Revolutionary America, Paris on the eve of its own revolution, 1790s Philadelphia, and plantation life at Monticello. Much anticipated, this book promises to be the most important history of an American slave family ever written.
Reclamation: Sally Hemings, Thomas Jefferson, and a Descendant's Search for Her Family's Lasting Legacy. Gayle Jessup White. Amistad, 2021. 288 pages.
Gayle Jessup White grew up in a black middle class family in Washington DC. She became a journalist and news anchor. ( I remember her at Savannah's WTOC in the 90s.) As a young teen, she had overheard talk that her father was descended from Thomas Jefferson, but he knew next to nothing about his family. She was intrigued and became enamored with Jefferson and his home Monticello, visiting numerous times, but she went on with her life and career. It wasn't until decades later that a Monticello historian and genealogist helped her discover the true story. What she discovered was that she was not descended from one of the Jefferson and Hemings children, but that she was, in fact, related to both Jefferson and Hemings separately. She also achieved her dream of landing a job at Monticello as Director of Community Relations, becoming, as she puts it, the first descendant of Monticello's enslavers and the enslaved to get paid to work there. The book is an interesting genealogical and historical mystery and, at the same time, a memoir of a black woman in America learning about herself, her family, and their place in America.
Two classics of passing fiction:
The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man. James Weldon Johnson. Sherman, French, & Co., 1912. 236 pages. Reprinted in 1927 by Alfred A. Knopf.
My latest classic read or re-read, one of the first books ever published in the US that presented a frank and honest portrayal of black life in the country, without offensive over-the-top stereotypes and broad comic characterizations. It is a fictional memoir that Johnson first published anonymously, but many readers assumed it was more factual than fiction. It's a frame story, with the unnamed narrator revealing his life story and the secret that overshadowed his life. Born in Georgia just after the Civil War, he is the child of a formerly enslaved woman and a wealthy white man. Knowing that they couldn't be together in Georgia, the father sent mother and child to Connecticut so that the boy could get an education and have a better life. Because he had a very light complexion, race and color, and all that those constructs entailed, were of no concern to the boy for his first few years in school, but then realizations hit him head-on, and he begins his life-long struggle with racial identity. He develops an extraordinary musical talent which opens up many opportunities for him, and he also realizes that he can operate within both worlds, black and white. He decides to dedicate his life to spotlighting black music and to introduce it to the world, elevating it to the attention it deserves - "glorifying" his race and their achievement. In the process, he has many experiences that remind him constantly of the overemphasis on race in America. Finally, on a return visit to Georgia, he witnesses a lynching, and that leads him to make a final decision. He gives up his race, his talent, and his "birthright" in exchange for security and safety, choosing to "pass" as white for the rest of his life, thereby becoming an "ex-colored man." The book is a brilliant depiction of race relations in America, colorism within a race, and the idea of "passing," forsaking one's true identity for expediency.
.jpg)
Named one of the best books of the year by The New York Times, The New Yorker, Time, NPR, Smithsonian Magazine, and Oprah Daily
In 1848, a year of international democratic revolt, a young, enslaved couple, Ellen and William Craft, achieved one of the boldest feats of self-emancipation in American history. Posing as master and slave, while sustained by their love as husband and wife, they made their escape together across more than 1,000 miles, riding out in the open on steamboats, carriages, and trains that took them from bondage in Georgia to the free states of the North.
Along the way, they dodged slave traders, military officers, and even friends of their enslavers, who might have revealed their true identities. The tale of their adventure soon made them celebrities, and generated headlines around the country. Americans could not get enough of this charismatic young couple, who traveled another 1,000 miles criss-crossing New England, drawing thunderous applause as they spoke alongside some of the greatest abolitionist luminaries of the day—among them Frederick Douglass and William Wells Brown.
But even then, they were not out of danger. With the passage of an infamous new Fugitive Slave Act in 1850, all Americans became accountable for returning refugees like the Crafts to slavery. Then yet another adventure began, as slave hunters came up from Georgia, forcing the Crafts to flee once again—this time from the United States, their lives and thousands more on the line and the stakes never higher.
With three epic journeys compressed into one monumental bid for freedom, Master Slave Husband Wife is an American love story—one that would challenge the nation’s core precepts of life, liberty, and justice for all—one that challenges us even now.
White Lies: The Double Life of Walter F. White and America's Darkest Secret. A.J. Baime. Mariner Books, 2022. 400 pages.
At the turn of the 20th century, Walter White's childhood in Atlanta was perhaps more comfortable than that of many black children across the South. His father was a mail carrier. His mother shopped at Rich's Department Store, where clerks politely called her "Mrs. White," but she wasn't allowed to try on clothes, return clothes that didn't fit. (The tea room wasn't an option; it did not exist until the 1920s.) Black customers had to trace their feet onto paper in order to shop for shoes, instead of trying them on. There was only one high school for black students, the costly private one operated by Atlanta University. Public schools for black students only went through 8th grade. Annual state and local spending per black student averaged about $2, one-tenth of the amount spent per white student. Black teachers were paid less than half of what white teachers were paid. Still, Atlanta race relations were relatively calm, until late September 1906 when white mobs murdered dozens of black Atlantans and burned many homes in a multi-day killing frenzy called the Atlanta Race Riot. According to White, it was at that moment, when an armed white mob besieged the family home and threatened to kill him and his entire family, that 13 year old Walter decided that he was black. Yes, you read that correctly --- decided. Walter White had straight blond hair, blue eyes, and fairer skin than some of the white men who killed blacks during the riot. Throughout his life, those that came into contact with White, black and white, without knowing him assumed he was white. He could have easily chosen to "pass" and live a much safer life. Instead, he resolved to "be black" and to devote his life to fighting for civil rights. As a student at Atlanta University, he attracted the attention of James Weldon Johnson who persuaded him to move to New York and to join the staff of the NAACP. Soon, he volunteered to risk his life multiple times to investigate lynchings across the country. Because of his appearance, murderers assumed he was a good "patriotic and Christian American" like themselves, and they proudly told him all the details of their horrible crimes, including naming leaders and active participants. White gathered information and prepared reports for publication and for government officials, often fleeing town just before his deception was discovered. If caught, he would have been just another victim. He did this many times as he worked his way up the ladder of NAACP leadership, becoming one of the most effective and respected civil rights advocates of the time. Things began to change, however, when squabbles with W.E.B. DuBois destabilized the organization, and his extramarital affair with a white woman came to light, White fell from grace, and his legacy was tarnished and largely forgotten. This excellent biography attempts to give his story the fullness and light that it deserves.
Incognegro: Renaissance. Mat Johnson and Warren Pleece. Dark Horse Comics, 2018. Book 1 of 5 in graphic novel series.
Obviously inspired by the life of Walter White, this is the first volume of a 5 volume graphic novel series. After a black writer is found dead at a scandalous interracial party in 1920s New York, Harlem's cub reporter Zane Pinchback is the only one determined to solve the murder. Zane must go 'incognegro' for the first time-using his light appearance to pass as a white man-to find the true killer, in this prequel miniseries to the critically acclaimed Vertigo graphic novel, now available in a special new 10th Anniversary Edition. With a cryptic manuscript as his only clue, and a mysterious and beautiful woman as the murder's only witness, Zane finds himself on the hunt through the dark and dangerous streets of 'roaring twenties' Harlem in search for justice. A page-turning thriller of racial divide, Renaissance explores segregation, secrets, and self-image as our race-bending protagonist penetrates a world where he feels stranger than ever before.
While it was always much more common for a black person to pass as white, there have been a few instances of going in the other direction.
Black Like Me, first published in 1961, is a nonfiction book by journalist John Howard Griffin recounting his journey in the Deep South of the United States, at a time when African Americans lived under the Jim Crow laws. Griffin was a native of Mansfield, Texas, who had his skin temporarily darkened to pass as a black man. He traveled for six weeks throughout the racially segregated states of Louisiana, Missiissippi, Alabama, Arkansas, and Georgia to explore life from the other side of the color line. Sepia Magazine financed the project in exchange for the right to print the account first as a series of articles.
Griffin kept a journal of his experiences; the 188-page diary was the genesis of the book. When he started his project in 1959, race relations in America were particularly strained. The title of the book is taken from the last line of the Langston Hughes poem "Dream Variations". (Wikipedia)
Several feature films have also been made exploring the theme of racial passing.
Passing (2021) Director: Rebecca Hall | Based on Nella Larsen's 1929 novella
Two childhood friends reconnect in 1920s Harlem. Clare has chosen to live as a white woman, while Irene lives as Black; their renewed relationship unsettles both women's carefully constructed lives. Probably the essential contemporary film for your post.
Imitation of Life (1934) Director: John M. Stahl | Based on Fannie Hurst's 1933 novel
Peola, the light-skinned daughter of a Black woman, attempts to pass as white and escape the racial restrictions of her time. Fredi Washington's performance makes this a particularly important film for examining the era's racial attitudes.
Imitation of Life (1959) Director: Douglas Sirk
The celebrated melodramatic remake features Sarah Jane, played by Susan Kohner, who rejects her Black identity and mother in pursuit of a life as a white woman. Compare it with the 1934 version to explore changing Hollywood representations of race and identity.
![Pinky [1949] par Elia Kazan](https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/MIyuE_t5y_RyiIalIquiij6kMHc28N_kgmtRSeSk8-JBEQPCXBvVwKiAr8frSOkIAwBiebQQAUwXlNUWaOTF8_947FUENOGu1zVdU1gILOUDVXanl8oPokLaLuFIAuoYhcB4C9FbGc0amk7Fn_ZiHckTHhU_-uyVF7ZA-z-jkCQ?purpose=inline)
Pinky (1949) Director: Elia Kazan | Based on Cid Ricketts Sumner's novel Quality
A light-skinned Black woman who has been passing as white while training as a nurse returns to her Southern hometown. Her return forces her to confront segregation, family ties, and the limits of racial privilege.
Lost Boundaries (1949) Director: Alfred L. Werker | Based on a true story
A Black physician and his family live as white in a New England community. Their carefully maintained identity comes under pressure when the doctor enters the Navy. Based on the experiences of Dr. Albert C. Johnston and his family.
Show Boat (1936; also 1951) Adapted from the musical based on Edna Ferber's novel
Julie, a performer on a Mississippi showboat, is revealed to have Black ancestry despite being perceived as white. The resulting crisis illustrates the reach of racial classification and the threat posed by laws policing racial boundaries.
The Human Stain (2003) Director: Robert Benton | Based on Philip Roth's 2000 novel
A college professor whose life unravels over an alleged racial slight has concealed his Black ancestry and lived as white for decades. The story connects passing to shame, secrecy, reinvention, and the personal costs of a hidden identity.
No comments:
Post a Comment