Thursday, November 30, 2023
Shelved: Roundup of Book Posts November 16 - 30, 2023
Thursday, November 16, 2023
Shelved: Roundup of Book Posts November 1 - 15, 2023
Wednesday, November 1, 2023
Shelved: Roundup of Book Posts October 16 - 31, 2023
"Who was the best English monarch?" David Mitchell ranks
Unruly: The Ridiculous History of England's Kings and Queens. David Mitchell. Crown, 2023. 448 pages.
A couple of weeks ago, David Mitchell appeared on my favorite talk show, "The Graham Norton Show," to promote his newly published history of English monarchs. I had never heard of the book, but I immediately grabbed my phone and downloaded the audiobook version before he even sat down on the couch. Mitchell is one of my favorite British comic actors, and I'm a huge fan of his appearances on the British celebrity panel comedy/quiz shows. He's incredibly witty, very snarky, and totally out of touch with popular culture, constantly ribbed by co-panelists for being ultra-"posh." And he has a history degree. I relate to him on many levels.
Unruly is all that I expected it to be. Mitchell takes the reader from the beginning - the fictional King Arthur - up to the reign of Elizabeth I (meaning that a volume 2 is in the works, I hope). He is a true iconoclast throughout, fully exposing the foibles and ridiculousness of the monarchs, their supporters and challengers, and the historians who have chronicled them over them over the centuries, with his characteristically biting Bitter humor in every paragraph. However, don't be misled. As the publisher's blurb says, Unruly is "A funny book that takes history seriously." It's also a seriously funny history book.
Lecture on the Election of 1932
Histocrats 7 Questions with Author
1932: FDR, Hoover, and the Dawn of a New America. Scott Martelle. Citadel Press, 2023. 407 pages.
Authors use phrases like "Dawn of a New America" and "turning point" in subtitles all the time, but some authors fail to prove their case. In 1932, Scott Martelle succeeds in laying out evidence that shows the significance of the presidential election between President Herbert Hoover and New York Governor Franklin Roosevelt, and he's written an excellent book about the candidates and the election.
Hoover and Roosevelt represented two different approaches to politics. Hoover was the traditionalist, believing voters would choose his record of administrative competence and conservative leadership over a naive, unproven upstart just spouting off platitudes. He saw campaigning as beneath him. Like nominees before him, he did not appear at the nominating convention and never really displayed a desire for the presidency. He played hard to get, "Well, if you really, really want me to be your president, I guess I will." For a large chunk of American history, it was considered unseemly to campaign for yourself; the candidates relied on surrogates to sling the political mud. On the other hand, FDR was one of the most politically astute politicians in history, in my mind second only to Lincoln among US presidents, and every waking moment for over a decade was spent preparing for his presidential campaigns. Rags to Riches orphan exemplar Hoover was seen as aloof, cold, uncaring and out of touch with average Americans, while privileged millionaire FDR convinced the poorest farmers that he understood their plight, and he won black voters over despite blocking all civil rights and anti-lynching legislation and even though blacks were often excluded from New Deal benefits. FDR's new political style changed presidential politics forever.
Martelle also does a great job of putting the election into the context of 1932. Many forces came together, creating a "perfect storm" that led to the transition: the Great Depression, the farming crisis, the Bonus Army, the Scottsboro Boys case, labor riots, the rise of socialism and communism, the KKK. I learned things from reading the book about each one, and Martelle weaves all of the threads together to tell a compelling story.
Monty Python - Ypres 1914
Great-Uncle Harry: A Tale of War and Empire. Michael Palin. Random House Canada, 2023. 336 pages.
You might know Michael Palin as a member of the great Monty Python comedy troupe or maybe from one or more of his excellent television travel series, but Great-Uncle Harry is a bit of a departure for Palin because it's a very personal family history, a quest in a way, decades in the making. During the height of the Monty Python days, Palin's family inherited a collection of diaries, photos, and letters, a treasure trove of family documents. Many of the items had to do with his Great-Uncle Harry, the brother of his grandfather. Harry had never really been spoken of in the family before. In fact, Palin had not known he had a Great-Uncle Harry, but he discovered that Harry had been one of thousands of young British men killed in 1916 at the Battle of the Somme. Palin was intrigued, but life intervened. Only in recent years did he decide to really dig deep and try to discover who Harry was. This book is the result. The finished product is an engrossing story, told of course with Palin's wit, not just of one victim of the Great War, but of the British Empire, as the subtitle foreshadows. The reader is drawn in for glimpses of British education, class system, and society as a whole through Harry's eyes, and Harry comes across as an ordinary, average bloke kind of flailing around and trying to find his place and fit in a rapidly changing world. Palin makes a real connection, not complete but at least a connection, to a family member he never knew and makes him accessible to the rest of us as well.